close
close

Should Bills QB have been allowed to return?

Posted on by Kennedy
Should Bills QB have been allowed to return?

Josh Allen didn't complete many passes on Sunday.

He completed the concussion exam in four minutes.

The Buffalo Bills quarterback passed protocol tests and was medically cleared to return in the fourth quarter against the Houston Texans, head coach Sean McDermott reiterated Monday.

Allen is not in the NFL's concussion protocol.

“Josh was cleared and returned to the game,” McDermott said. “I know that from our medical staff on the sidelines.”

Allen's head bounced off the ground when he was brought down on an incomplete pass in the 23-20 loss. Buffalo stumbled and Allen was sent to the medical tent to be evaluated for a concussion. The Bills got the ball back four plays later after a strip sack and a fumble recovery and Allen got back into the game.

The Bills were criticized by fans and media for allowing Allen to continue playing and allegedly giving him smelling salts as he walked back onto the field.

“Josh is a warrior,” coach Sean McDermott said in his postgame press conference. “Took a pretty good hit out there and came back for his team and his teammates.”

According to an international consensus statement from the Concussion in Sport Group, performing a comprehensive examination for a possible concussion takes at least 10 to 15 minutes. Allen was in the medical tent within four minutes.

“Four minutes is going to be a pretty tight window,” Dr. Katie Rizzone, associate professor of orthopedics at the University of Rochester. “There are confirmatory tests and questions. Asking about the symptoms they are having would take a minute or two. Then you will give him a physical exam even if everything was negative and he felt fine. The examination is difficult, but doable. “a professional athlete in four minutes.”

The CBS broadcast initially said Allen had a chest injury. Allen told reporters after the game that he was injured Chest and ankles during the game before.

“Big shot to the chest. Twisted my ankle,” Allen told reporters after the game. “They reported me for hitting my head, but they felt well enough to go back in.”

Did Josh Allen suffer a concussion?

The Bills said no.

Concussions are not always obvious because they are based on science, symptoms and testing, Rizzone explained. There is no blood test or scan to diagnose it.

Neurologists look for headaches, nausea and dizziness. They ask the patient orientation questions – where they are, what their score is – and then carry out more complex focus and concentration exercises, such as naming the months backwards. A physical examination will include any abnormalities in the pupils, eye movements, and nerves in the neck and face. Athletes undergo balance tests such as: B. standing with your eyes closed or on one leg. Apps can detect how much someone sways when they try to stay still.

Rizzone was surprised that Allen returned so quickly.

“That would be a pretty comprehensive exam to do on the side,” said Rizzone, the team doctor at the University of Rochester and SUNY Brockport. “You could see at first that he wasn’t feeling well. But we don't know what happened in that tent. Adrenaline is a powerful drug and the medical staff could have tested him quickly and he could have been normal on all of those tests.”

The response time is difficult to estimate and is one of the slowest return times, Rizzone said. In football, a delay of a few microseconds is important.

It is unknown whether Allen lost consciousness.

Allen could have avoided head trauma in the impact. It's also possible that Allen develops symptoms in the next few days and will have to undergo NFL concussion protocol.

How did Josh Allen get injured?

The quarterback was pulled to the ground by his ankles by defensive end Mario Edwards Jr. as he threw the ball over linebacker Azeez Al-Shaair.

Allen's right buttock, hip and shoulder first hit the ground before the right side of his helmet bounced off the turf. His face was laid before he rolled onto his back. Both of Allen's arms were bent 90 degrees at the elbows, he flexed his hands in the air and was attended to by medical staff.

Allen told reporters that an independent certified athletic trainer, acting as a locker room observer, asked to evaluate him for a concussion.

Allen was slow to bounce back the week before against the Baltimore Ravens after suffering a forearm shiver from 338-pound defensive tackle Travis Jones. multiple shots on the same game. Allen flew into the air and landed on his back as his head snapped back. Allen said after the loss that he had aggravated his lower back when he hit the ground but would be fine.

Josh Allen injury timeline: How long was he out of the game?

Allen missed a Bills offensive play and the entire process from injury to return to the game took six minutes in real time. It took four minutes from entering the medical tent to jogging back onto the field.

  • 3:43 p.m.: Allen's head bounced off the turf as he was tripped by Houston's Mario Edwards Jr. Allen threw an incomplete pass on the third-and-8 and the Bills stumbled with 3:18 left in the fourth quarter.
  • 3:44 p.m.: Allen walked to the bench under his own power and was surrounded by Bills staff
  • 3:45 p.m.: He went to the medical tent with trainers and a neurotrauma consultant
  • 3:49 p.m.: Buffalo's defense recovered from a fumble, Allen was cleared to return, came out of the medical tent, put on his helmet and returned to the game after missing a play.

Did the Bills give Josh Allen smelling salts?

Fox Sports 1 host and former NFL linebacker Emmanuel Acho posted a video with a screenshot of a Bills employee appearing to hand Allen smelling salts.

“We all saw Josh Allen seemingly get knocked out, but they just threw him smelling salts and went right back into the game,” Acho said on X. “As if that would undo the head trauma he just suffered.”

What are smelling salts?

Smelling salts are a mixture of ammonia and other chemicals that are inhaled to stimulate or restore consciousness. They can be used to treat fainting spells. They smell strongly of bleaching cleaner.

The smelling salts irritate the inside of the nose and force deep breathing, which clears the nasal passages and oxygenates the brain. They make the user feel more awake and alert, giving them a rush of adrenaline and energy.

There are medical concerns about using them for medical purposes and to counteract the effects of head trauma.

“This can be dangerous because symptoms of a concussion could be masked, leading to delayed diagnosis,” according to Medical News Today. “In addition, a rapid return to sport with a high risk of re-injury could worsen the consequences of a head injury.”

What were Josh Allen's stats after his injury?

Allen failed to complete a pass for five attempts after returning to the game. He threw incomplete passes from the Texans' 15-yard line to James Cook and Curtis Samuel, and the Bills kicked a field goal to tie the game at 20-20.

Allen took a 3-0 lead with three deep pass attempts on the Bills' final possession, a three-play stretch for which McDermott took the blame after giving the Texans time to get the ball back and score a game-winning field goal .

Allen completed 9 of 30 passes – a career-worst 30% completion rate – for 131 yards.

NFL analysts are accusing the league and the Bills of letting Josh Allen return

Fans and analysts were shocked and upset that Allen was allowed to return to the game.

NFL analyst and former quarterback Chase Daniel posted on The process is flawed. He looked like he was outside.

Dr. Chris Nowinski, a former WWE wrestler, neuroscientist and founder of the Concussion Legacy Foundation, wrote on X: “It's crazy that Josh Allen was reinstated after this hit. Even if he says he's fine, why bet on the franchise QB that concussion symptoms won't be delayed? Protocol aside, how do we take such risks just weeks after another Tua concussion?”

What is the NFL concussion protocol?

If a player suffers an impact to the head during a game, the player will be subject to concussion protocol if:

  • The player shows or reports symptoms or signs suggestive of a concussion or a puncture injury (a nerve pinch injury). or,
  • The team's athletic trainer, the ATC spotter in the booth, the team doctor, the NFL game official, the coach, the teammate, the UNC (Sideline Unaffiliated Neurotrauma Consultant), or the UNC in the booth initiate the protocol.

The player must then be immediately taken to the sideline or stabilized on the field to undergo the concussion assessment. This is outlined in a concussion game day checklist. This may include a sideline examination, a locker room examination and a flow chart that determines whether or not a player is fit to return to play.

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *